With an explosive Christmas party at the Silvas' home that ends with Joi and Erana being kicked out, the group tries to decide if friendships are dead or salvageable. Winter and Yusha continue their romance as Winter pushes for an "I love you."

The drama between the Silvas and Tylers continues when Little Jamie gets upset with Quick on social media. Clifton and Carmen's bond grows and the men question if Clifton is in a throuple. Winter's sister warns her about moving too fast with Yusha.

Erana's feelings of Carmen being a threat to Joi and Clifton's relationship triggers something from the Tylers' past. Quick invites everyone to a Wizards game, but the Petties' presence sets Ashley off as things take a turn for the worse.

After the ugly argument at the Wizards game, Quick feels a way after hearing Clifton disrespected Ashley, and the group is divided over who's to blame. Ashley confronts Erana about abandoning her for a friendship with Joi. Winter plans a couples' getaway.

The couples leave for Winter's Valentine's ski trip. The couples have a good time riding the bus together, but the Petties opt to make their own way and stay elsewhere. Things get even more awkward at the group dinner when Quick brushes off Clifton.

The couples are on a Valentine's Day ski trip, and tensions are still high with the Petties at odds with almost everyone but the Tylers. An accident on the slopes ends with crutches. Black tries to confront Joi, but she storms out over a surprise guest.

After a disastrous intuitive healing session, the Tylers convince Joi to try again with Ashley, but Joi's left waiting in the cold. Winter is turned off when Yusha sticks up for Joi. The couples return home, and Jamie checks in with a retired cop buddy.

Ashley is upset that her mother hasn't spoken to her in months; Yusha's defense of Joi continues to cause problems for Winter; Jamie goes to group counseling with other retired cops; Ashley and Joi meet for a one-on-one to squash their beef.

Ashley’s book signing motivates her to meet up with her mom after not speaking for months. Joi, Clifton and Carmen scout a location for Clifton’s beard launch, where Joi reveals that she made up with Ashley, but that Ashley still doesn’t like Clifton

Host Carlos King welcomes the cast to the reunion stage to get to the bottom of failed friendships and romantic relationships; tensions flare immediately, putting Ashley and Erana at odds as well as Clifton and Quick.

After an explosive ending, the cast returns for the reunion; while everyone chimes in about the Christmas Eve Eve party and who was in the wrong, Yusha joins the stage and gets a cold reception from Winter.

Carlos King continues to get to the bottom of the couples' issues by bringing out someone that everyone seems to have a problem with: special guest Carmen; Joi reveals her pain caused by both Carmen and Clifton.